front page  ·  comicbook reviews  ·  interviews  ·  comics  ·  merchandise  ·  columns  ·  contact  ·  newsfeed: rss xml  ·  links


Notes on searching
Browse the archive

 

 

Fantastic Four: True Story #1

Posted 14 Aug 2008

Writer: Paul Cornell
Artist: Horacio Domingues (interior), Niko Henrichon (cover)
Letters: Dave Lanphear
Publisher: Marvel


 4.50 out of 5 Stars

Reviewed by Adam McGovern

 


Something is trespassing on the very source of possibility, the human imagination as embodied in works of fiction, and the Fantastic Four – whose focus, as a family unit, has always been as intimate as their adventures are epic – must enter the mental dimension of literature and culture itself to free everything back up.

Like the prose works that writer Paul Cornell clearly cherishes (and are specifically visited by the FF in this first issue), it’s a dimension of charm and peril alike, from Edgar Rice Burroughs to Jane Austen – Cornell enjoys how the greatest fiction can tap both childhood and lifelong hopes and fears, and he very much includes comics in that founding canon of our personalities.

True Story is not quite like anything else being published.”

The FF are ideal vessels for such an expedition; not only does their concept admit a lot more humor than most superheroes (which is in abundance in this often storybook/satire-flavored mini), but they are among the few Marvel heroes who are truly archetypal rather than iconoclastic (as a family, they are the primal social unit; other than that there’s the jester/trickter Spider-Man, so much like the literary Loki or, hmm, the African god Anansi the spider man; and the Hulk, locus of appetite/animus and intellect/civilization; and beyond them not much else). The FF as an idea connect with the type of basics of our fantasies and self-image that this book’s odyssey will touch on.

That trip entails an acrobatic system of self-reference and paradoxes (as the characters become increasingly aware of – though often surprised by – their shifting position in and out of reality as they see it and story as we do), and Cornell coordinates it like a master choreographer – and standup comic; there’s incredible intricacy under the hood here, but Cornell keeps your eye on exactly the magic tricks of witty banter and personal tenderness he wants you to see (and does it much better than the ten-metaphor-pileup I’ve just written). The eye is also rewarded by Horacio Domingues’ art, drawing equally from manga, children’s books and Not Brand Echh as befits the story’s cultural cross-traffic.

The series stands up with, and maybe sets off, the meta-stories of Alan Moore, whose characters navigate the closed book of their lives while Cornell’s FF negotiate a changing ferment of narratives they thought they knew (literally intervening in the events of Sense and Sensibility; believing themselves into victory or assuming themselves into defeat; etc.). To Moore reality seems to be a vast tapestry whose threads are imperceivable to any one person but are all already in place; to Cornell it seems to be a swirling ocean of endless possibilities.

True Story is a worthy companion to Virgin Comics’ Tall Tales of Vishnu Sharma (which also concerns an assault on fantasy, though in a bit more binary way, and was originally titled, a-ha, End of Story), and almost seems a knowing satire of DC’s “52 universes” (or was that Heinz ketchup and relish?), with the FF not meeting their What If? counterparts but entering the realms of Tarzan, Rikki-Tikki Tavi, Dante (a character in his own fiction), et al. It gives more of a taste for its sources than Marvel Illustrated, and is one of the truest signs of the company’s evolution – the real action-adventure nailbiter would be one where Cornell himself travels back in time and tries to pitch this tricky, literate idea in the Bob Harras era.

Stewarding Marvel’s most familiar characters well while feeling not quite like anything else that’s being published, True Story is good for you in every way. It’s only four issues, so don’t wait for the book.

—CCdC—

 

[Read the previous review]

[Read the next review]

 

 

Cover image used without explicit permission in accordance with the "Fair Use" provision of US copyright law.

 

Contact CCdC - Changelog - Colophon - Newsfeed

(c)2007 ComicCritique.com, all rights reserved
Problems viewing this site? feedback_@comiccritique.com