front page  ·  comicbook reviews  ·  interviews  ·  comics  ·  merchandise  ·  columns  ·  contact  ·  newsfeed: rss xml  ·  links


Notes on searching
Browse the archive

 

 

Amazing Spider-Girl #18

Posted 26 Mar 2008

Writer: Tom DeFalco (script and co-plot)
Artist: Ron Frenz (pencils and co-plot)
Letters: Dave Sharpe
Ink: Sal Buscema
Colors: Bruno Hang, Impacto Studios
Publisher: Marvel


 5.00 out of 5 Stars

Reviewed by Adam McGovern

 


For a book about youth and impulsiveness, Spider-Girl sure is a lesson in longevity and wisdom. Limited runs drive the market these days — not just miniseries in an industry where boundaries have to be set for short attention spans and fickle finances, but also at-most yearlong turns by any one creative team on books that go forever, so as to give packagability to graphic novels and rotate the market magic of successful teams to other titles. This can give a satisfying artistic completeness to the timespan; rather than suspending a good thing before it starts, it can make storytellers tighten their structure, deepen their characters and concentrate their ideas. But Spider-Girl is a study in how well-shaped and surprising an ongoing series can be.

“DeFalco, Frenz and Buscema use the time to build a novelistic texture to their characters’ personalities and the bumpy arc of their true-to-life experiences.”

It may be because the several-times cancellation-bound (but always-rescued) book’s creators don’t take forever for granted, but even if they had 100 issues contractually guaranteed, this would be the way to make a comic worth reading; DeFalco, Frenz and Buscema use the time to build a novelistic texture to their characters’ personalities and the bumpy arc of their true-to-life experiences. At this point (counting a title-change and renumbering) Tom DeFalco has written 117 of the last 118 regular issues, longer than Stan Lee spent on Spider-Man (and longer than any other female-headlined title has lasted at the Marvel Men’s Club), with, like Stan, two defining art teams (first Pat Oliffe & Al Williamson, and currently Ron Frenz & Sal Buscema). The unheard-of sales of the digest collections through Scholastic, and the activist fanbase that has saved the regular comic several times, show that this creative braintrust may be classic, but is in no way unfashionable.

In any case freshness is a given in this back-to-the-future book, since it extends the anything-can-happen ethic of Marvel in its first two decades, with a mature and retired Peter Parker, a settled-down yet still-dynamic Mary Jane (remember her?), and their burdened yet optimistic daughter in a world of many changes but wide-open possibility (“Brand New Day”’s pop-art positivity owes a big debt to this book). May “Mayday” Parker, popular and well-adjusted in a way her dad never was, is not just a refreshing change from the dourness that defined the old book, but an interesting metaphor for the nervous-breakdown generation of success-obsessed kids; Peter & MJ may not have had her doctoral college picked out since she was in nursery school like many yuppie couples, but May’s puberty-triggered powers multiply her turmoil about how to please her parents and peers, do the right thing and be herself.

This issue is not any particular landmark, and that’s the point; crack open a Spider-Girl of almost any number and you’ll find, as here, ingeniously entwined plotlines and parallel situations, unexpected switches in incident and behavior, and affecting characterization. In this case, we have the nuanced (if irredeemable) Ditko-costumed stealth-tech assassin Deadspot, trading gallows repartee with Spider-Girl while sensibly sticking to her job-description to kill someone else; the fearsomely portrayed Hobgoblin, allying with our heroine in a betrayal of convenience against various assembled mob rivals; a ticking clock as May’s little brother undergoes an operation she can’t show up for due to a detour for the family business; and some high-school courtship soap opera with a skillfully staged missed connection among two romantic rivals for her when May finally makes it to the hospital. Every 15 issues or so a plot-point may not add up or a finale will fall flat, but that’s a better ratio than the longrunning weekly TV shows that Spider-Girl most resembles in structure and longevity. Tune in, and you’ll find the book matches many of those in enduring appeal and importance too.

—CCdC—

 

[Read the previous review]

[Read the next review]

 

 

Cover image used without explicit permission in accordance with the "Fair Use" provision of US copyright law.

 

Contact CCdC - Changelog - Colophon - Newsfeed

(c)2007 ComicCritique.com, all rights reserved
Problems viewing this site? feedback_@comiccritique.com