front page  ·  comicbook reviews  ·  interviews  ·  comics  ·  merchandise  ·  columns  ·  contact  ·  newsfeed: rss xml  ·  links


Notes on searching
Browse the archive

 

 

Captain America: The Chosen

#1-2

Book Released: 26 Sept 2007
Posted 18 Oct 2007

Writer: David Morrell
Artist: Mitch Breitweiser
Letters: Cory Petit
Colors: Brian Reber
Publisher: Marvel Publishing, Inc.


 3.80 out of 5 Stars

Reviewed by J. W. DeBolt Jr.

 


In Afghanistan, Corporal James Newman is living the hardship of active combat. We see the war from his eyes. He knows why he’s there: “If I help make this country safe, I hope to help make America safe.” Yet it is a far from easy task. The endless fighting has drained him, causing him to despair. He misses his family — including a newborn son. With minimal support — his wife had to buy and send him body armor — and being unsure of his enemy — which hides among the populace — Newman is reaching the limits of his strength to fight.

“Dark and moody, Mitch Breitweiser’s art matches the serious tone of the story. I would purchase the rest of the series based on the art alone. ”

Then, improbably, he sees Captain America, who offers words of encouragement and fights at his side. Cap helps him rescue a G.I. who is pinned down in the middle of a firefight, speaking the soldier’s mantra “Courage. Honor. Loyalty. Sacrifice.” After that rescue, and helping several more soldiers in battle, Newman reunited with his unit — which saw no trace of Cap and think the corporal is just imagining things in the stress of battle. But whether Cap was physically present or not, his spirit was enough to carry Corporal Newman through the crisis of confidence.

Corporal Newman’s unit is next sent in to a cave to locate and destroy a terrorist weapons cache. The interior confines cause Newman to flash back to his childhood to a point when he was scared, trapped in a junkyard car trunk. With his fear of the cave’s confines drawing in around him, he and his team locate the cache, but they also find a terrorist there who throws a grenade. The explosion brings part of the roof down, trapping all but Newman. He begins to try to dig everyone out, but is almost overcome with fear and despair. At that point, Cap appears to him again. He reminds Newman of his inner strength — how he saved himself through his persistence and by not giving up. Cap gets Newman to call upon the same inner strength in these circumstances, and Newman finds the will and wherewithal to dig the men out.

We learn that Cap himself is in the lab where he was created, on a table, hooked up to life support and other, unknown, machines. He tells the corporal that he is dying.

This story may take place just after Cap was shot and before he died of his wounds. The scientists trying to keep him alive are apparently doing something else, something involving the transfer of consciousness or at least telepathy. Perhaps the government is trying to get one last bit of usefulness out of their investment before they squeeze it dry.

Where writer David Morrell (Creepers, Nightscape) is going with this is unclear. He has told the same tale twice with separate facts — the soldier finding his inner strength through Cap’s inspiration. So what more can be said? We do have the mystery surrounding Cap’s circumstances — how did he get to the lab? What is to become of him? How long has he got to live? Is this after he was shot? Is this the real Cap? At one point, Cap is in uniform on his lab table, and at another, he isn’t. Is that artistic license? Or are there two Caps? At one point, he seems to be with S.H.I.E.L.D. — is that Nick Fury from the back? But at another point he’s in a different room.

We do get the hint of another subplot when the artist gives us a close-up of a technician with the cryptic caption, “If you get close to Captain America, you’re one step closer to the President.”

The first two issues of this six-issue series give precious little information. This appears to be mainly about the fittingly named Newman becoming a new and more confident man.

The art by Mitch Breitweiser (Annhilation, Ultimate Fantastic Four), however, is outstanding. Dark and moody, it matches the serious tone of the story. I would purchase the rest of the series based on the art alone. Some of the best panels: the expression on the face of the terrorist in the cave as he pulls out the grenade pin; Cap handing Newman his helmet with the photo of Newman’s baby in the helmet strap; the central three panels of the scene where Cap lifts a humungous piece of debris and hurls it into a rooftop sniper nest across the street. The painterly style gives the explosions and action an ethereal quality, perhaps echoing the dreamlike environment surrounding Newman. No one else can see Cap; Newman questions his own sanity.

Perhaps this is series will result in Newman becoming the new Captain America. The job has already been turned down by a couple of people. This may be Newman’s testing prior to his draft.

According to the author, the first issue sold out but is available in a second printing. The third issue comes out this month (October) and a hardbound version of the complete series will be sold in June 2008.


—CCdC—

 

[Read the previous review]

[Read the next review]

 

 

Cover image used without explicit permission in accordance with the "Fair Use" provision of US copyright law.

 

Contact CCdC - Changelog - Colophon - Newsfeed

(c)2007 ComicCritique.com, all rights reserved
Problems viewing this site? feedback_@comiccritique.com