front page  ·  comicbook reviews  ·  interviews  ·  comics  ·  merchandise  ·  columns  ·  contact  ·  newsfeed: rss xml  ·  links


Notes on searching
Browse the archive

 

 

Scalped #4

Posted 14 May 2007

Writer: Jason Aaron
Artist: R.M. Guera
Artist: Jock (cover)
Colors: Lee Loughridge
Publisher: Vertigo


 5.00 out of 5 Stars

Reviewed by Adam McGovern

 


Vertigo is justly proud of its oft-quoted reputation as “the HBO of comics.” But several of its series could also collectively be thought of as “That Other ’70s Show.” The decade remembered mostly for its fashion statements by current sitcoms and bands is recalled by Vertigo writers as a time of military quagmires abroad and niche civil wars at home.

Peter Milligan’s brilliant Human Target run brought the Weather Underground up to date a few years ago; the recent “Brother #38” arc in Simon Oliver’s Exterminators revisited the killing fields of Cambodia and some furtive surviving culprits over here; Jason Aaron’s The Other Side brought the Vietnam War back to life with frightful fidelity; and Aaron’s Scalped reflects on the eerily erased-from-history unrest in the Nixon-era Native American community.


“In Scalped #4 irony piles up like anonymous bodies.”


There was a time when America’s former tenants took over whole islands, shot it out with federal agents and were targeted by numerous lethal government plots, and Aaron fast-forwards this legacy to a present day of abject poverty, mob-like casino scams and desperately narrow options (with superb art, both spontaneous as a sketch and sharp as photojournalism in its sense of elusive moment and telling detail, by R.M. Guera).

The layers of hopelessness are as dense as the intrigues and counter-plots are intricate in this first part of a new story arc. Though it has the feeling of an interlude after the jarring violence of the earlier three issues, it’s charged with an anxiety of buried secrets and simmering consequences that may be even more intense.

Dash Bad Horse is a wayward son of the Prairie Rose Reservation, who drifts back to become an enforcer for the corrupt Chief Red Crow, who’s building a multimillion-dollar casino and seeking to both rule the local rackets and suppress protests from more public-spirited tribe members. But the chief answers to more shadowy interests, while Dash may even raise that ante – since he’s really an undercover fed investigating the chief’s dirty dealings.

In Issue #4 irony piles up like anonymous bodies, as we peer into a past where two other FBI agents were gunned down by the chief in his younger days as a would-be revolutionary, a secret he keeps with the main casino protestor, Gina — his former comrade and Dash’s estranged mom. Red Crow is troubled by the remnants of his conscience as he comes to tell Gina he can’t guarantee her protection from his even more ruthless bosses, and Gina goes on a fruitless search to connect with Dash before she leaves the Rez on a prison visit to the fallguy doing time for the decades-old shooting. Meanwhile Dash is dallying from his usual circuit of headknocking as a tribal policeman to obsessively surveil his old flame, the chief’s daughter Carol — a suicidal slip that also might just quiet any suspicion of his actual mission, if he survives to complete it.

The final scene, with Gina unknowingly driving past Dash sleeping in his police car in a ditch right inside the reservation limits, as she guiltily goes to a rendezvous with a casualty of the same government her son now secretly works for — a portrait of perfect futility for both his desire to escape the Rez and her dreams of standing by it — is as heartbreaking as hardboiled crime fiction gets. And a bravely unblinking look at the unfinished business of clearing our country’s conscience. How everybody gets out of this one is a mystery worth every reader keeping their eyes on.

—CCdC—

 

[Read the previous review]

[Read the next review]

 

 

Cover image used without explicit permission in accordance with the "Fair Use" provision of US copyright law.

 

Contact CCdC - Changelog - Colophon - Newsfeed

(c)2007 ComicCritique.com, all rights reserved
Problems viewing this site? feedback_@comiccritique.com