front page  ·  comicbook reviews  ·  interviews  ·  comics  ·  merchandise  ·  columns  ·  contact  ·  newsfeed: rss xml


Notes on searching
Browse the archive

 

 

Justice Society of America #1

Posted 30 Jan 2007

Writer: Geoff johns
Artist: Dale Eaglesham
Ink: Art Thibert
Publisher: DC Comics


 5.00 out of 5 Stars

Reviewed by John L. Daniels Jr.

 


DC Comics once again have reinvented The Justice Society of America with the help of their most prolific writer Geoff Johns.

Over the past 62 years, the Justice Society of America team has gone through many changes. From its original conception in All Star Comics #3 (published by National Publications) until its demise with issue #57 through its rebirth at DC Comics with issue #58 in 1976. The team returned as the Super Squad, with new members featuring the Star-Spangled Kid, Robin from Earth II, and it was here readers were introduced to Power Girl. In 1981, DC Comics renamed the title and team into the All-Star Squadron.

Ah, yes the cover of the issue All-Star Squadron #1 by Rich Buckler of Hawkman, Dr. Midnite, and the golden age Atom looking at potential prospects is ominous and reminiscent of this brand new #1 issue cover.

The past Justice Society of America and Justice League of America stories surrounding the selection process of new members has continually kept readers in suspense. Who will be picked and hold the distinct honor of becoming a new member of one of the longest standing teams in comic book history?

In a selection process there is always someone who thinks they are the only individual to have the ultimate say. In meetings you have your occasional bantering and your finger points and the inevitable raising of the voices, which turns into hollering and as we witnessed lately in some government election results, pure fisticuffs. I proclaim that superheroes and government officials should devise and use a protocol for selection process (hey let's be realistic they are role models for us civilians).

Well Mr. Wildcat is coughing up a fur ball about the brand new blood selected for The Justice Society of America, for which he is a founding member. I guess Wildcat is tired of all the many applicants over time that he had to bring up as babes in the woods and teach them the real way to be a champion, having character. Nope that is not it; his way is a swift left to the jaw and is done with villains like Degaton or Vandal Savage.

The JSA is a combination of the core founders mixed in with the new breed of young whippersnappers. So what is ahead for this new team of heroes? The writing by Geoff Johns is amazing, he seems never to get tired of writing about the adventures of the JSA, and that is a treat for the many JSA and Geoff Johns fans.

As with any first issue in a series, characterization is crucial, so readers may view many changes in the following months to catch the reader's attention. In other words, how long will it take before a villain interrupts the selection process and the real action begins? Not long at all. The artwork by Dale Eaglesham is vibrant and expressively presented. Eaglesham's artistry has the same qualities of presenting a golden age look to the characters. Along with inking extraordinaire Art Thibert, both talents could accompany the days of the X-men series when Thibert teamed up with Jim Lee.

In one panel, Green Lantern is placing the photograph of Liberty Belle on the cork board; the detail of his hand and ring magnifies distinction and human anatomy detail. While comparing some of the panels in this issue and simultaneously looking at a reprint of the old All-Star Comics #1 (and the All-Star Comics reprint #58 as well as All-Star Squadron #4), I studied the distinctive qualities that make artists of any era unique. Only one word comes to mind: “skill.” Thibert and Eaglesham have it.

Justice Society of America #1 is a colossal first issue. Not in size; this issue is colossal in the depth of storytelling and the exciting artwork. After reading the issue I felt the adrenaline running, I did not want the story to end. I cannot wait until the next issue. As the character Damage said in a panel about joining the JSA, “What could you possibly offer me?” My reply summed up in a single inquisitive word: “Excitement!”

—CCdC—

 

[Read the previous review]

[Read the next review]

 

 

Cover image used without explicit permission in accordance with the "Fair Use" provision of US copyright law.

 

Contact CCdC - Changelog - Colophon - Newsfeed

(c)2006 ComicCritique.com, all rights reserved
Problems viewing this site? feedback_@comiccritique.com